top of page

I'm switching provider!

ree

Recently, I transferred my ISA from HL to Interactive Investor. The switch went well and I'm happy with Interactive Investor's service.


I have now initiated the transfer of my SIPP.


Two reasons:


First, I was becoming increasingly frustrated that HL would not allow me to trade some stocks that I wanted to. HL stipulates that they must settle on Crest. Frontline is just such an example. I can't trade it on HL, but I can on II.


Second, costs. I will save a not inconsiderable amount of money by switching. To start with, the annual charge will be quite a lot less. On top of that, I should make quite a saving on foreign exchange charges. With HL, every time I buy or sell an overseas stock, I am charged a prohibitive foreign exchange fee - in my mind, it should be market rate plus 10 basis points. Interactive Investor also charges a high forex fee, but it does give you an option to settle in the currency of the stock being traded. So, if I were to reduce one of my Canadian stocks, I could choose to keep the C$ in a separate pot, thus avoiding the foreign exchange fee. If I then buy another C$ stock, I can settle it from the C$ pot.



I have been with HL a long time and have, on the whole, been impressed with the service. It was a difficult decision, but in my case, I think switching makes sense.


I am definitely not suggesting people follow my lead, but it is worth checking that one is getting the best service and not being overcharged. Those savings compound over the years. A lot will depend on the size of portfolios - for me, it makes sense.




 
 
 

13 Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
Rated 5 out of 5 stars.

Hi John, I am about to do similar - am awaiting my TF cash withdrawl to come through and will then be off to II. I reckon between trading costs and management fees (which are huge for HL on unit trusts) I should save between £2-3k pa.

My PF has gone back to having a lot of UT's within it (which it hadn't for the last 5 years) and as I manage multiple ISA's & SIPPs for the family my trading volumes are quite high.

How long did the transfer process take you? And any tips for making it easier?

Like
Replying to

With my ISA it took just two to three weeks to complete but within that there was very little interuption to trading

Like

Rated 5 out of 5 stars.

Hl has a new owner………

Like
Replying to

You never know, the new owners might improve things. I could always switch back one day if it made sense.

Like

John - how long did the switch take?

Like
Replying to

When I switched the ISA, it was all done within two weeks. There was also little interuption to trading. As long as it was in my HL a/c, I could trade. One day they were all in HL, the next in II. All very efficient.

Like

Hi John, I’m with II for my ISA which is where I get caught by their high Forex conversion rates - +/- 1.5% each way in or out of the foreign currency. The problem with an ISA is you can’t leave your dollars in dollars, you’re not allowed multiple currencies, unlike with a standard trading account and SIPPs.

Like

Rated 5 out of 5 stars.

The FX fee is a real bugbear for me. A reasonable spread is OK but the outperformance of international equities is impaired by this HL policy

Like
bottom of page